Forged: Why Fakes are the Great Art of our Age, by Jonathon Keats

fakes-keatsAs a literary forger of sorts, I enjoy reading about forgeries and forgers’ lives. There is a tendency in such books to repeat stereotypes – the forger as the injured and overlooked, the forger as the masterful yet unoriginal technician etc. What is refreshing about Keats’ book is the way that it avoids the usual moralising that shores up consensus so that he can get to deeper understandings raised by specific forgeries.

There isn’t a strong argument that builds through the book to justify the title. It’s more like a set of mini-biographies that explore what are usually unexplored positive aspects to forgeries.

The book starts with a story from the renaissance, as recounted by Vasari, which illustrates something surprising about forgery. The concept has different meanings at different times and in different places. During the renaissance, an undetectable copy of a master work showed equal skill, and placed the copyist alongside the master. By the 20th century, the skill to a forgery had become irrelevant: criminalisation had seen to that.

Beneath our current orthodoxy, argues Keats, is an anxiety that means ‘No authentic modern masterpiece is as provocative as a great forgery. Forgers are the foremost artists of our age.’ What a forgery shows at any given time in any given place is what’s valued and why. Forgery is even revealing about the things that it ignores. Keats  elaborates on these notions in his introduction. He works through examples of forgery throughout the ages. From each it’s possible to see how different copies are used for different reasons. Holy relics, for example, had since the middle ages been subdivided and distributed to keep up with the demand to venerate them. Within this, forged relics appeared, yet their worth was something they earned. So long as they could perform miracles, they remained (or became) genuine.

There’s also good attention given to the 20th century. The story of Elmyr de Hory is particularly colourful. He not only forged modern masters, but also made a forgery of himself by presenting himself as a collector selling the works. His biography was written by Clifford Irving, who went on to be a forger himself: Irving attempting to fake the dictated biography of billionaire recluse, Howard Hughes. There was, incidentally, a book about that forgery too – Hoax – and I shall post about it in good time.

Keats also recounts the life of Tom Keating, who towards the end of his life, was offered a TV series on Channel 4 in the UK. It was something that hooked me as a teenager who’d taken to oil painting. Luckily, someone has uploaded it!

What Keats’ book achieves is to explain why forgeries are an integral part of any cultural system. They lurk within markets. They fool experts. Yet these uncertainties offer a challenge to what we value and why. It’s simply a cop-out to avoid this challenge by targeting the character of forgers and dividing the world into a comforting binary between a good real and its bad copy.

This entry was posted in Art, Keats, Jonathon, Non-Fiction, Reviews and tagged , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

4 Responses to Forged: Why Fakes are the Great Art of our Age, by Jonathon Keats

  1. Sounds interesting – and I do question our obsessions with authenticity, because so many works of art in the past were done by discipies of a great master, a tendency that was taken to its ultimate end by Warhol. I guess I think the deciding factor should be whether we find something beautiful.


  2. Jonathan says:

    It makes me think of times on ‘The Antiques Roadshow’ when the expert can’t tell whether the object is real or a fake but says it’s worth £10 if it’s fake but £1,000 if genuine. If the fake is that good then shouldn’t it be close to the price of the original?


  3. Jeff says:

    I love watching the researchers on Fake or Fortune wrestling with their feelings about a painting they admire but have one or two doubts about. The difference can be the price of a small flat.


Leave a comment ...

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s